A mother’s love will never die.
For the most part, the notion of this is sweet and reassuring. But, in the case of She Came Back, it’s one girl’s worst nightmare.
Years after the significant loss of her mother, Charlie (Amybeth McNulty) remains reluctant to approve of her father Michael’s (Kris Holden-Ried) marriage to Donna (Athena Karkanis). As she makes her way to the ceremony on the wedding day, Charlie gets into a car accident. Her heart stops, and in that moment on the other side, she encounters her mother again, feeling her embrace and longing for her touch. However, as she is revived, she is pulled away from her mother’s grasp, bringing back with her a promise that her mother won’t leave her again.
Never Letting Go
Not long after the accident, Charlie begins to hear her mother through other people, as her presence overtakes them in disturbing ways and dangerous ways. Dr. Keith Mitchell, played by Colm Feore, attempts to help Charlie understand these unsettling occurrences.
Her family remains skeptical despite her certainty that her mother is reaching out. As the truth unfolds, Charlie uncovers startling revelations about her mother, leading to the frightening realization that this reunion may not be as joyous as she once hoped.
The narrative of She Came Back possesses a spellbinding quality, capturing the disturbing nature of the events while preserving the profound tragedy that resonates deeply.
Amybeth McNulty delivers a truly captivating performance, showcasing her as a formidable talent. Kris Holden-Ried is equally well-cast, and his portrayal of Charlie’s father adds depth to their relationship, grounding the narrative with authenticity. The screenplay by Chris John and Christina Vegas navigates familiar themes with a fresh and engaging perspective.
Director Megan Follows brings this ghostly tale to life, creating a film brimming with suspense. She Came Back is both atmospheric and intimate, highlighting the talent of its lead actress and centering her as the film’s emotional core. The film features some truly terrifying moments and visuals that make it feel as if Charlie—and, by extension, the audience—will never escape.
This carefully crafted blend of drama and horror sets She Came Back apart, enveloping its story in a fragility that respects its difficult subject matter while remaining shrouded in darkness. It intertwines the fear of the unknown with the primal dread of losing loved ones and confronting our mortality.
With its unsettling imagery and profound subject matter, the film delivers a powerful heartfelt impact. I admire how it captures both poignancy and a disturbing edge, creating a truly resonant experience.
Conclusion:
For some reason, She Came Back isn’t receiving the attention it deserves, but it certainly should. This well-crafted horror film leverages powerhouse performances and exceptional storytelling that’ll haunt you long after the credits.
She Came Back is currently available VOD.
Does content like this matter to you?
Become a Member and support film journalism. Unlock access to all of Film Inquiry`s great articles. Join a community of like-minded readers who are passionate about cinema - get access to our private members Network, give back to independent filmmakers, and more.